Veils Deplorable but Permitted
President Obama recently criticized a French law that prohibits Muslim girls and women from wearing body- and face-covering garments in public schools.But French President Sarkozy this week gave his support to attempts to bar Muslim women from wearing body-cloaking robes such as the burqa. What's your view? Is this a private religious matter or a public/government one? Is the burqa welcome in America?
The first thing one learns about human beings in the Bible is that they are created in the image of God. Although not intended as a physical depiction, it has long been understood that the first place one looks to see a symbol of God in this world is in the face of the person next to you. To obscure that gift for half the population is a shame, even a diminishment of God's many reflections in this world. We have every right to deplore the practice of covering women's faces. It seems paradoxical that the antidote to male desire is to make women hide. It would seem to be men's problem, yes?
We cannot, however, forbid it, save for security reasons. For example, if at an airport it is deemed important to be able to check ID's etc, the mask must slip. But short of that, freedom consists in permitting practices one likes and dislikes, so long as they pose no public hazard. Still, one's faith should shine in one's face, not force one to hide it.
By
David Wolpe
|
June 25, 2009; 10:16 AM ET
Save & Share:
Previous: Slavery Apology Should Lead to Penance, Restitution |
Next: The Veil in Context
Posted by: educated | June 25, 2009 3:40 PM
Report Offensive Comment
Hello Louise10,
"Of course government can prohibit wearing a burqa, and it should. There are basic norms of dress everyone must observe."
Governments can prohibit anything it wants, but that is not where most of us live. In a free society choice of dress is one of the freedoms that an individual makes for his or her own expression. A government of a free society should not prohibit the burqua. The exclusion to that should be for security purposes alone, and in that case it is the face that should be visible. The basic norms of dress are usually culturally based, (as is the burqua), and in a multi-cultural society the edges of culturally acceptable dress get expanded.
In my town, up until recently, it was allowable to walk in public naked, per an old city ordinance. It was not culturally acceptable and so few did it, and it is no longer legal. But in pre-Christian Polynesia nakedness was customary, as it was in many earth cultures.
I would consider reasonable, for security and unhindered social interaction, disallowing of masks and veils that obscure view of the face. I do not think it appropriate to legislate style of dress, though.
Posted by: justillthen | June 25, 2009 2:45 PM
Report Offensive Comment
Of course government can prohibit wearing a burqa, and it should. There are basic norms of dress everyone must observe. No one can appear fully or partially naked in public. No adult can wear a mask in public (in my home town, this even applies to adults on Halloween night), since this could easily be a security risk. Children cannot wear masks during the ordinary school day. No one can drive a car with partially obscured vision.
Posted by: Louise10 | June 25, 2009 1:33 PM
Report Offensive Comment
The comments to this entry are closed.

Twitter










Are you living in the real world? Or a protected, wealthy environment where you go to nice cocktail parties, and your kids elite schools, and all you know are other well-educated, respectful, polite folks. Come down to earth a bit and visit our other world...I cannot believe you defend the burka! How would your precious cocktail parties flow, if all the women guests were wering them, your children's schools, your workplace...go ahead, tell me!
I suppose you willingly allow any heinous practice and its expression in our public places...Is there any practice you would ban? For Heaven's sake! We forbid every inhuman thing, from cock-fighting, dog-fighting, protect every species, protect children and ban drugs that may harm...yet clothe this practice in religion and everyone it all for it. Most of these commentators will not be running into hordes of women such as these on their streets as so feel quite comfortable with the occasional apparition...Thanks alot all you high-minded folks...You are safe knowing you won't have to really live with the consequences...